Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Time to consider a targeted HPV vaccination programme for male military recruits
  1. William M J Sharp1,
  2. T Nadarzynski2,3 and
  3. N E Dufty4,5
  1. 1 DPMO, Medical Centre, RNAS Yeovilton, Yeovil, UK
  2. 2 Department of Sexual Health Services, Solent NHS Trust, Southampton, UK
  3. 3 Department of Psychology, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
  4. 4 Department of Sexual Health, Birmingham Heartlands Hospital, Birmingham, UK
  5. 5 Department of Military Medicine, Royal Centre for Defence Medicine, Birmingham, UK
  1. Correspondence to William M J Sharp, DPMO, Medical Centre, RNAS Yeovilton, Yeovil BA22 8HT, UK; willsharp{at}hotmail.co.uk

Abstract

Human papillomaviruses (HPV) are the most common type of sexually transmitted infection in men but also related to high-risk cancers. This article considers the epidemiology of HPV in the male military population, the UK vaccination programme and the current UK Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation recommendations. Military men may not benefit from HPV herd immunity and may have a different risk profile; vaccination may in turn reduce the operational burden of HPV-related disease within this population. Military men may benefit from a targeted vaccination programme, and the paper calls for urgent consideration of approaches that could protect them from acquiring HPV.

  • Infectious Diseases
  • Sexual Medicine
  • Epidemiology
  • Public Health
  • Primary Care

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Human papillomaviruses (HPV) are the most common sexually transmitted infection (STI) in men, but the majority of cases are asymptomatic and clear naturally within 2 years.1 HPV has been associated with genital warts as well as anogenital and oral cancers in both sexes. HPV prevalence in men has generally been comparable to the rate of HPV infection in women; thus, any fluctuations in female HPV infections would most likely result in similar HPV infections in men. Before the introduction of female-oriented HPV vaccination in the UK in 2008, the lifetime risk of acquiring HPV was estimated to be around 75% for most sexually active individuals.2

There is little reliable data on HPV infection rates in men because HPV prevalence varies between countries and social groups, making it difficult to generalise. One multicontinental study of heterosexual men has indicated that 9 per 100 become HPV-infected each year.3 In the prevaccination era, HPV prevalence in men peaked in early adulthood (age group 21–25 years old), then remained fairly constant with increasing age.4 Approximately 16% (range 1%–84%) of men were actively infected with HPV.5 In about 70% of cases, HPV infection is cleared within 8 months, and over 95% of men do not present with HPV infection beyond 18 months from diagnosis.6 Less than 1% of infected men present with any HPV-related clinical symptoms; hence, most of them are not aware of their infection.

Only two population studies have estimated HPV prevalence in the UK. One study conducted between 1999 and 2001 as part of the National Survey of Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles II asked participants to provide urine samples in order to detect HPV.7 The results showed that 17% of men were positive for any HPV type and 9.6% for high-risk types. The peak HPV infection occurred approximately 5 years after the initial sexual debut. Another study by Desai et al conducted in England used HPV antibody markers to detect previous HPV infection.8 The study recruited men aged 10–49 years old as part of a seroepidemiological survey in 2002–2004. The results showed that 7.6%, 2.2%, 5.0% and 2.0% of men were seropositive for types HPV6, HPV11, HPV16 and HPV18, respectively. The findings support the evidence that only a proportion of men previously infected with HPV might seroconvert. Hence, initial HPV infection not resulting in antibody response could reoccur. Nevertheless, both studies were conducted before the introduction of female HPV vaccination, and therefore more research is needed to identify whether HPV vaccination of women has had an impact on HPV rates in men in the UK.

Persistent HPV infection with HPV16 and HPV18 is associated with cancers of the cervix, anus, vagina, vulva, penis and oropharynx.9 While HPV-related penile and anal cancers are relatively rare (~1 per 100 000), it is estimated that approximately half of all head and neck cancers in men (25 per 100 000) are due to persistent HPV infection.10 Two epidemiological analyses have shown that HPV-induced oropharyngeal cancers are increasing and are affecting younger men.11 12 Despite a decrease in tobacco use (universally associated with oral cancers), there has been a rapid increase in oropharyngeal cancers in a sexually active population, especially in individuals who practise oral sexual intercourse.13 UK data on oropharyngeal cancers demonstrated that at least 37% of oral tumours are associated with HPV infection.14 Thus, there is an urgent need to protect men against HPV-related oral cancers.

HPV6 and HPV11 cause anogenital warts associated with significant physical and psychological morbidity, as well as substantial healthcare costs of approximately £58 million related to diagnosis and treatment in the UK.15 Before the introduction of HPV vaccination, there were around 40 000 cases of male genital warts each year, giving an incidence of 150 per 100 000 men per year.16 It is predicated that in the postvaccination era, the incidence of HPV-related diseases in men would decline, mirroring the sharply declining HPV incidence in women; however, the exact impact on male HPV infections is yet to be established.

In 2008, the UK introduced routine HPV vaccination of adolescent girls at school. This female-oriented programme has been very successful, achieving coverage of over 80% and dramatically decreasing the HPV infection rates in young women.17 Data from Australia, which implemented a similar vaccination strategy with quadrivalent HPV vaccination, showed a decline in HPV and genital warts in women and heterosexual men of corresponding age, suggesting that vaccinating one sex could lead to ‘herd protection’ — a population-level-acquired protection against a virus among both vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals.18 However, herd protection would not safeguard men who have sex with individuals from unvaccinated populations, such as men who have sex with men (MSM), who do not benefit from female HPV vaccination. Hence, in 2015 the UK Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) recommended targeted HPV vaccination for sexually active MSM below the age of 46 delivered through sexual health clinics to tackle HPV-related anogenital warts and anal cancers in this population.19 Although the effectiveness of this strategy is uncertain, it is important to consider which other groups of men might not benefit from the herd protection following female-only HPV vaccination.

HPV in military men

Military men could also fall within the category recommended for vaccination by JCVI. Military recruits are susceptible to HPV infection. HPV seroprevalence of men aged 17–26 years entering military service in the US Armed Forces was initially 14.5%, and was higher than in the US civilian population National Health and Nutritional Examination Survey (NHANES) HPV prevalence survey (4.2% and 7.2%, in men aged 20–24 and 25–29, respectively)20 21 Around 34% of the male service members recruited had seroconverted to HPV at the 10-year point from entry.20 A study from Denmark by Hebnes et al of 2460 men made up of conscripts and male employees at barracks found that up 42% were positive for HPV.22 These studies indicate that military men are at substantial risk of HPV infection.

Approximately one-quarter of the UK Armed Forces are under 25, the age range that experiences the highest rates of STIs.23 24 This ‘at risk’ population frequently deploys overseas and may have the opportunity for sexual contact with the local population in countries without an HPV vaccination programme. In turn this reduces the ‘herd immunity’ effect from just having sexual encounters with those vaccinated in the UK. Genital warts are a common presentation in our UK Armed Forces personnel. Previous sexual health data collected from military sexual health clinics showed they were the most common STI reported in UK Military genitourinary clinics and on operational deployment. Over 60% of the attendances to the deployed sexual health service during an operational deployment related to genital warts, with over 95% of these attendances from male military personnel.25

US studies, including that of Agan et al, suggest that the prevalence of genital warts is already relatively high in military recruits, prompting a question about the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of targeted HPV vaccination; however, an even greater proportion (34.2%) actually seroconverted to one or more of the vaccine HPV types within the following 10 years, demonstrating large numbers of preventable infections.20 21 Currently, male recruits in the UK Armed Forces are not vaccinated, unlike their female counterparts who will have received vaccination as part of the UK HPV vaccination programme, raising questions as to the equity of the current policy. By vaccinating the male recruits, the disease burden of HPV could be reduced, which operationally would reduce attendances relating to anogenital warts and improve medical fitness for operations; reducing the HR HPV would also likely lead to a reduction in the number of HPV-related cancers in this population.

While a significant proportion of heterosexual men are likely to benefit from female-oriented HPV vaccination in the UK, men who access sexual networks within unvaccinated populations will continue to be at risk of HPV-related diseases.19 The current MSM HPV vaccination pilot is currently only accessible to MSM located within England, making this beneficial vaccination unavailable via this route to military MSM serving in all military bases outside England. The most effective solution would be to vaccinate both sexes at school before they become sexually active; however, the gender-neutral HPV vaccination strategy is currently not cost-effective in the UK and it is unlikely that it could be introduced anytime soon.19 The UK male military population is not currently vaccinated but makes up 89.8% of the 197 150 trained strength of the UK Regular Forces.26 27 In the absence of gender-neutral HPV vaccination in the UK, military personnel should be considered as a population within this high risk of acquiring HPV-related diseases. The development of targeted HPV vaccination for UK military men would require systematic identification of HPV prevalence, the benefits of female-oriented HPV vaccination and potential cost-effectiveness of this strategy, similar to HPV vaccination for MSM. Due to their increased risk of STIs, in particular HPV-related genital warts, which could be acquired overseas, and their operational impact, an examination of approaches that could protect military men from acquiring HPV is urgently required.

References

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.